How to Know What to Charge for a Brand Deal

Ask a creator how they came up with their sponsorship rate and you'll usually get one of a few answers:

"I just picked a number."
"Someone in a Discord told me what they charge."
"The brand told me what their budget was, and I said yes."

None of those are wrong, exactly. When you're starting out, you work with what you have. But at some point, guessing stops being a strategy and starts being a way to leave money behind.

The creators who stop guessing have one thing in common: they know what their past deals paid.

Why rate benchmarks from the internet don't work

There are plenty of articles and spreadsheets floating around that tell you what creators "should" charge — CPM-based formulas, per-platform rate cards, industry averages.

The problem is that none of those numbers are about you.

Your rate isn't just a function of your follower count. It's a function of your engagement rate, your audience demographics, your niche, your platform mix, the category of brand, the type of deliverable, whether it's a long-term partnership or a one-off, and a dozen other variables. A beauty creator with 200K followers and a highly engaged 18–24 female audience commands a different rate than a tech creator with 200K followers and a broad general audience — even for the same deliverable.

The only benchmarks that actually apply to you are the ones built from your own deal history.

What a useful rate history looks like

Not all closed deals are created equal. To actually use your rate history for pricing, you need to be able to slice it.

What you want to know, when you sit down to price a new deal:

• What have I charged for YouTube integrations versus dedicated videos?
• What does a brand in this category (SaaS, food, fashion, fintech) typically pay me?
• What did my last three Instagram Story campaigns go for?
• Is my rate trending up year-over-year, or have I been flat?

If your deal history is a spreadsheet with deal values in a column, you can't answer any of those questions quickly. If your deal history is organized by platform, deliverable type, and brand category, you can answer all of them in thirty seconds.

That's the difference between data and information.

How to actually use rate history in a negotiation

A brand emails you. They want a YouTube integration and an Instagram Story. They mention they have a "limited budget."

Without a rate history, you feel that pressure immediately. Limited budget — okay, what do I say? You make a judgment call based on vibes.

With a rate history, you open your last five YouTube integrations, see that you've been getting $X–$Y for that deliverable, and you know your floor. You also know whether this brand's category historically converts well for you, which affects how much you want to fight on rate.

You still might accept a lower rate for a brand you genuinely want to work with. That's a valid business decision. But it's a choice, not a guess.

The slow way rates go up

Here's something that doesn't get talked about enough: creator rates don't go up because creators ask for more. They go up because creators have a reason to ask for more.

That reason is almost always some combination of audience growth, performance data, and market awareness. But for a lot of creators, that last one — market awareness — is just absent. They don't know what comparable deals pay because they haven't built anything to track it.

The result is that a creator who's been doing brand deals for three years might be charging 30% more than their first deal. A creator who tracked everything from the start and used that data to negotiate might be charging 200% more — not because they're more talented, but because they had something to point to.

Start tracking now, even if it feels early

If you've only closed a handful of deals, your rate history isn't going to tell you much yet. That's fine. Start tracking anyway.

A year from now, you'll have 10–15 deals with enough variety to actually see patterns. Two years from now, you'll have a real benchmark. The earlier you start, the sooner that data becomes useful.

The worst version of this is the creator who's been doing brand deals for three years and has no record of any of them — not what they paid, not what they included, not what the deliverables were. At that point you're not just missing future leverage. You've lost the past.

---

Paperclip builds your rate history automatically from closed deals — organized by platform, deliverable type, and brand category. So the next time a brand asks what you charge, you actually know.